Seas Reading Response

The Seas article and the theory of ecology reminded me a lot of actor-network theory and affect theory in Anthropology. Actor-network theory is a social theory influenced by the hard sciences; an interaction of agency within a network (objects, animals, people, etc. are all agents in this). Actors are agents, and networks are structure and interactions etc. Affect theory is the theory that visceral forces that influence our thinking and judgements even though they are non-cognitive and and noncorporeal. Affect theory especially problemetizes anthropology and discussions of autonomy. I know the Seas piece was not really about the theories, but since I studied these first, my understanding of the piece is through them, and my understanding of ecological theory is again filtered through my understanding of these two anthropological theories.

That being said, I trying to understand the ecologies or networks between my group, the Lifetime Fitness staff, and the administration would really be beneficial to us. We have already been trying to navigate the ecology surrounding our issue, even if we’ve not been calling it that. There are aspects to the administrative side of the class that we had not previously known, such as the CPC review. We are trying to figure out all the angels we can use to approach the subject, so that we can formulate a much more informed argument. In being able to  navigate the different ecologies and let your argument evolve based on what you find, the interactions you’ve had, and so on, we would then have much stronger and effective rhetoric.

Also, previous articles already made it clear that we should be careful in how we communicate with our stakeholder(s). Seas reinforced that idea of careful comminication. For Seas though, the communication was not so much about not offending your stakeholder and more about increasing the effectiveness of your rhetoric; although in reality not offending your stakeholder and increasing the effectiveness of you rhetoric work towards achieving the same goal.

Questions for Serenity

Serenity is a Transy alum and former faculty, so she could give us some perspective on how Lifetime Fitness has already progressed. For that reason, my questions are really about Lifetime Fitness.

  1. What was Lifetime Fitness like when you were enrolled here? What were the focuses of the class? and if you can remember, what were the course objectives?
  2. What were your thoughts/feelings/experiences with the course?
  3. How do you think other students were perceiving the course?
  4. The course was recently under review, do you know anything about what changes were made then? Do you know what issues were addressed in the review?

Questions for Teddy

We read two pieces for today, one from Cassie Barnhardt and one be Georgianna Martin.

  • In the Barnhardt piece, she said that tactics usually resonate more when they create disruption. Based on what you’ve seen and done, to what extent is this true?
  • The Maxine piece said that no matter the level that student activism occurs, activists are visible. I found this statement to be a little questionable anyways because I feel like it’s worded to seem like an absolute. Anyways, have you found that activists are always visible, or are there times you’ve felt invisible as an activist?

May 3 Response

Student activism can take many forms, but it seems, based on the Kezar & Maxey piece, the Heller article, and some other news articles, student activism today typically takes form in protests, rallies, marches, etc. Of course, this media representation could be because these forms of student activism are the loudest and the most visible. Casey Smith, a correspondent for USA Today wrote an article much like the other two, where they reviewed several different universities and highlighted the kinds of activism they saw. Smith interviewed Angus Johnston, a professor at City University in New York. Johnston said, “In the last two to four years, we’ve seen protests on campuses where there haven’t been in a very long time, we’ve seen marches and rallies at traditional activist campuses drawing in a lot more students than they have in the past.” (Smith). I think that Smith, through Johnston, makes a pretty important point with this; student activism is on the rise.

After this introduction, Smith explores various campuses and details the forms of activism seen. However, the examples given aren’t always a protest or a march as student activism can take other forms. For example, activists at Kent State started a student organization for sexual assault awareness; Ball State has a Progressive Student Alliance (another institution approved student activist organization) that is an activists group that fights for student raised issues;  students at the University of New Mexico formed an activist group to demand more Native American recognition and rights.

I think the important thing to note about each of these examples is that while they are trying to make a change, they are doing so in such a way that they are still playing by the rules of their respective institutions. I’m not sure that creating an organization would help with my groups project, but the willingness to negotiate, to participate in the institutional structure is definitely something that could be beneficial. And while some of these examples of student activism may not be so applicable to the Lifetime Fitness reform, I think they’d be interesting for other groups to look into as they continue their research. Also, the Smith article started out talking about protests, and I think that definitely would not be helpful to m groups project. Protests don’t happen a lot at Transy, and I think it’d be overkill to try and start one. Even if the Lifetime Fitness issue is ignored by administration and never brought back under review, I highly doubt this is big enough that students here be rally around a protest.

Smith, Casey. “Is This the Golden Age of College Student Activism?” USA Today. Gannett Satellite Information Network, 23 Mar. 2017. Web. 03 May 2017.